| 1) |  | Empyrium - Songs of Moors & Misty Fields (1997) | 9.35 (180 votes) |
| 2) |  | Empyrium - A Wintersunset (1996) | 9.23 (113 votes) |
| 3) |  | Haggard - And Thou Shalt Trust... the Seer (1997) | 9.23 (111 votes) |
| 4) |  | Betray My Secrets - Betray My Secrets (1999) | 9.21 (9 votes) |
| 5) |  | Lacrimas Profundere - Memorandum (1999) | 9.20 (75 votes) |
| 6) |  | Betray My Secrets - Betray My Secrets (1999) | 9.16 (50 votes) |
| 7) |  | Nagelfar - Virus West (2001) | 9.16 (29 votes) |
| 8) |  | Haggard - Awaking the Centuries (2000) | 9.14 (107 votes) |
| 9) |  | Dark Reality - Blossom of Mourning (1996) | 9.14 (18 votes) |
| 10) |  | Empyrium - Weiland (2002) | 9.13 (102 votes) |
| 11) | Kreator - Pleasure to Kill (1986) | 9.12 (81 votes) |
| 12) | Nocte Obducta - ...Doch Lächeln die Blutleeren Lippen / Begräbnisvermählung (1998) | 9.11 (9 votes) |
| 13) | Moonblood - Split with Inferno (1999) | 9.11 (9 votes) |
| 14) | Moonblood - Split with Asakku (1998) | 9.07 (8 votes) |
| 15) | Lacrimas Profundere - The Crown of Leaving (demo) (1997) | 9.06 (6 votes) |
| 16) | Empyrium - Where At Night The Wood Grouse Plays (1999) | 9.04 (94 votes) |
| 17) | Moonblood - The Winter Falls over the Land (demo) (1995) | 9.04 (12 votes) |
| 18) | Nargaroth - Herbstleyd (1998) | 9.03 (87 votes) |
| 19) | Haggard - Eppur Si Muove (2004) | 9.03 (78 votes) |
| 20) | Nargaroth - Rasluka Part II (2001) | 9.02 (67 votes) |
| 21) | Lacrimas Profundere - Burning: a Wish (2001) | 9.01 (62 votes) |
| 22) | Evereve - Seasons (1996) | 9.01 (62 votes) |
| 23) | Riger - Des Blutes Stimme (2002) | 9.00 (10 votes) |
| 24) | Kreator - Flag of Hate (1986) | 8.99 (49 votes) |
| 25) | Adorned Brood - Erdenkraft (2002) | 8.99 (24 votes) |
